Before Giotto, art had been largely decorative or dogmatic; he revealed that it could also be a shared human experience – something to look at rather than look up to. He infused his paintings with a newfound sense of humanity, setting his figures in natural, emotionally resonant scenes. Inspired by the philosophy of the Franciscans, who replaced the somberness that had long pervaded Christianity with a message of joy, Giotto captured their belief that the beauty of nature was divine and that all men were brothers. Unlike their rivals, the Dominicans, the Franciscans spoke from the heart rather than the mind – and Giotto translated that spirit into art.
Giotto grounded his figures firmly on the earth and displayed a genius for simplicity. For the first time, he captured genuine human emotions – grief, fear, pity, and joy – in lifelike form. He elevated art from mere symbolism to a mirror of humanity. His contribution to modern art has been celebrated for more than half a millennium; he prepared the soil that nourished the Renaissance and all that followed.
Giotto’s world was one of natural beauty – Tuscany – and of relative freedom – Florence. Perhaps even more importantly for his art, he grew up during a period of unusual peace and prosperity. He was among the first artists to distinguish himself from his peers in the painter’s guild, the Medici e Speziali, gaining the independence to innovate. His frescoes and altar panels, displayed in churches throughout the city, brought his genius to a wide audience. Giotto came of age just as Florence itself was rising to prominence, and like his adopted city, he was pragmatic, confident, and unabashedly materialistic – yet he managed to live without known enemies or detractors.
Giotto was a precocious talent, reportedly discovered by Cimabue when he was just a boy. Cimabue, along with two leading Roman artists – painter Pietro Cavallini and sculptor Arnolfo di Cambio – deeply influenced Giotto, particularly through their emphasis on giving subjects substance, naturalism, and a sense of three-dimensional form. Early in his career, he also benefited from the patronage of Florence’s Black Guelfs, who had exiled their rivals, the White Guelfs, among them Dante.
For centuries, it was believed that a young Giotto painted the 28-fresco cycle in the Basilica of St. Francis at Assisi. That attribution, however, was forcefully challenged by German scholar Friedrich Rintelen in 1912 and remains controversial to this day. Many scholars now argue that Giotto may have been responsible for the overall program – its compositional planning, iconographic design, or preliminary sketches – even if he did not personally execute every scene. Arguments against Giotto’s authorship point to the use of certain materials not found in his confirmed works – such as white lead – and to compositional flaws, including crowded scenes and key events placed off-center or rendered obscure. Giotto, by contrast, was known for his economical storytelling and his unwavering focus on the central subject.
Giotto’s masterpiece is the cycle of forty frescoes depicting the lives of Mary and Jesus, painted in the Arena Chapel in Padua around 1305. The building itself was a mural painter’s dream – 134 feet of uninterrupted flat walls capped by a soaring barrel-vaulted ceiling – and it was commissioned by the banker Enrico Scrovegni. As was said at the time, “Enrico defended his family’s name against a verse by Dante—who consigned his father to Hell among the usurers in the Divine Comedy – with a church by Giotto.”
The Arena Chapel frescoes are widely regarded as a turning point in Western art – a bridge between the medieval and the modern. Their revolutionary power lies not in a single innovation but in Giotto’s masterful synthesis of realism, emotional depth, and narrative clarity, which broke decisively from the stylized conventions of Byzantine and Gothic art. In these frescoes, Giotto reintroduced humanity into the sacred: he transformed flat, symbolic figures into lifelike people, replaced decorative patterns with believable spaces, and infused divine scenes with genuine human feeling. They stand as the first great expression of the Renaissance spirit – born nearly a century before the Renaissance itself. After completing the Arena Chapel, Giotto painted two even larger – and perhaps more impressive – fresco cycles in Padua: one in the Basilica of St. Anthony and another in the Palazzo della Ragione, or “Palace of Reason.” Tragically, both have been almost entirely lost to history.
Rare among artists of his talent, Giotto was both very wealthy by middle age and a shrewd businessman. He bought and rented property throughout Florence, underwrote – and profited from – loans to modest merchants, and even leased high-end looms at premium rates to the city’s large workforce of textile spinners.
Near the end of his career, between roughly 1320 and 1328, Giotto painted the Bardi and Peruzzi Chapels in the Basilica of Santa Croce in Florence. These two fresco cycles – depicting scenes from the life of St. Francis (Bardi Chapel) and the lives of St. John the Baptist and St. John the Evangelist (Peruzzi Chapel) – are widely regarded as crowning achievements of early Italian painting and had a profound influence on the course of Renaissance art that followed.
Giotto’s figures convey emotion, weight, and individuality in ways unprecedented in European art. In The Death of St. Francis, for example, monks grieve with authentic sorrow – their faces contorted, their bodies bent in mourning. This emotional immediacy resonated with viewers and marked a striking departure from the abstract, symbolic Byzantine style that had preceded him. Giotto also introduced the illusion of depth and physical weight long before true linear perspective was formalized by Brunelleschi. He rendered the human body as solid and grounded, using shadows and carefully modeled drapery folds to give form and presence. This approach was a revolutionary step toward the naturalism that would come to define the Renaissance.
Next, Giotto transformed Christian storytelling from spiritual abstraction into human drama that ordinary people could relate to. Saints are no longer mere icons; they are flesh-and-blood figures, experiencing real emotions and placed in believable settings. This naturalism made divine events feel immediate and emotionally accessible – a profound cultural shift in religious art. Finally, Giotto’s frescoes in Santa Croce showcase his mastery of composition. Each scene is carefully structured, both spatially and psychologically. He arranged figures and gestures to lead the viewer’s eye toward the emotional core of the narrative – a technique later refined by artists such as Masaccio and Leonardo. Santa Croce was further adorned and enriched by some of Giotto’s most talented students, including Taddeo Gaddi, Maso di Banco, and Bernardo Daddi.
In 1334, Giotto returned to Florence to assume the role of capomaestro (chief master) of the construction of the Florence Cathedral, as well as chief of public works for the city. He designed the 270-foot Campanile, though construction had only just begun when he died in 1337. After Giotto’s death, Siena briefly emerged as the leading center of Italian art, guided by artists such as Simone Martini and the brothers Pietro and Ambrogio Lorenzetti.
Giotto grew up in a period of relative peace and prosperity, which is reflected in the vitality and optimism of his art. After his death, Florence was shaken by a succession of crises: a costly and fruitless military campaign against Lucca that drained the city’s treasury and manpower (1341–43); crop failures caused by severe hailstorms (1341); the collapse of the Bardi and Peruzzi banking houses following King Edward III of England’s default (1345); a new wave of papal tax collectors sent by Avignon Pope Clement VI (1342–52); the Black Death (1348); and the Ciompi rebellion (1378), among others. This cascade of trauma appears to have been mirrored in Florentine art, which retreated from the humanity and relatability of Giotto back toward the austerity and otherworldliness characteristic of the previous century.
Once again, art became harsh, didactic, and propagandistic, with figures in hieratic paintings portrayed as aloof, severe, and admonitory rather than compassionate. Mourning, self-reproach, and misery permeated the Florentine style of the mid- and late fourteenth century. In the wake of the plague, the warm, empathetic Christ of Giotto’s Arena Chapel was replaced by a stern, omnipotent ruler, to be obeyed and worshiped through his temporal agents – particularly the Dominican order, the new guardians of the faith.
The Florentine painter Andrea di Cione, better known as Orcagna, exemplified this grim shift. In the Strozzi Altarpiece (1357) he depicted Christ not as an innocent child or suffering martyr, but as an omnipotent King, dispensing Church doctrine and conferring ecclesiastical authority. Similarly, Francesco Traini’s The Triumph of Death (1350) and Andrea da Firenze’s The Way of Truth (1368) convey the trauma and fear wrought by the catastrophes of the period.
The innovations of Giotto were not resurrected until seven decades after his death. Masaccio (1401-1428) is widely regarded as the pivotal figure who bridged the expressive naturalism of Giotto with the fully realized humanism of the Italian Renaissance. Building on Giotto’s innovations, Masaccio introduced a revolutionary sense of linear perspective, realistic spatial depth, and volumetric figures that inhabited convincingly three-dimensional space. His frescoes, particularly in the Brancacci Chapel, combined dramatic narrative, psychological realism, and a mastery of light and shadow, setting a new standard for naturalism and influencing generations of Renaissance artists, including Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, and Raphael. In effect, Masaccio transformed the lessons of Giotto into a sophisticated visual language that fully embodied the Renaissance ideals of proportion, perspective, and the human experience. Masaccio served as the final turning point in western art from the medieval to the modern.
What's Tim Reading Now? 
Leave a comment